| Date | Theme | King | Queen |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | Once Upon a Time | Anthony Grieco | Giuliana Renda |
| 2020 | Color Your World | Erik Youngblood | Katherine Wood |
| 2019 | Treasures of the Sea | Joe Fazzio | Jenna LaBruzza |
| 2018 | A Stroll in the Park | Frederick Guy Fleming, Jr. | Madeline Jane Magee-Cheramie |
| 2017 | Carrollton Jukebox | Joe Larocca | Kelly Van Geffen |
| 2016 | A Krewe for All Seasons | Lee Cotaya | Shannon Lundin |
| 2015 | A Night at the Opera | Mark Terral | Kathleen Garitty White |
| 2014 | Carrollton Goes Two by Two | Chris Bode | Shelley Schexnayder |
| 2013 | Laissez les Bon Temp Rouler | John Echeverri | Alexandra Pfefferle |
| 2012 | Celebrate Louisiana | Kirk Leonard | Ashley Michelle Cuccia |
| 2011 | Broadway on Parade | William Taylor, III | Andre’a Michelle Foote |
| 2010 | It’s a Small World | David Bruce | Rachel Cuccia |
| 2009 | A Fair to Remember | Leonard J Rizzo | Erin Marie VanGeffen |
| 2008 | Name That Tune | Ralph Romaguera | Katherine Elise Dileo |
| 2007 | Celebrate Good Times | John Williamson | Ashleigh Nicole Foote |
| 2006 | Ball: They All Asked for You Parade: Blue Roof Blues | Carroll Denis VanGeffen, Jr. | Heather Marie Haydel |
| 2005 | A Quest for History | Dino Nash | Liddy Romaguera |
| 2004 | Streets on Parade | Richard Catoire | Brittni Williamson |
| 2003 | Childhood Memories | Dr. Ronald Aslett | Laura Ashley Cotaya |
| 2002 | Splendors of Nature | Morris Daniels | Ashley Elaine Schiavi |
| 2001 | A Musical Odyssey | Jim Falter | Carol Keene Romaguera |
| 2000 | A Family Affair | Gregory J. Bruce | Maurina Ann LaRocca |
| 1999 | Through the Years | Capt. John Stanton White | Leslie Jeanne Slaton |
| 1998 | Carrollton Shoots the Movies | Clement Joseph (Rusty) Buckman | Catherine Steele Dunn |
| 1997 | Believe It or Not | Albert Peter Bode, Jr. | Alison Marie Bode |
| 1996 | Carrollton Salutes Famous Americans | William LaGrange, Sr. | Lori Angela Carroll |
| 1995 | Carrollton Travels the USA | Wayne Michael Lee | Lena Marie Nuccio |
| 1994 | 70 Years of Nostalgia | Willis John Williams, Jr. | Erin Martin Bruce |
| 1993 | Famous Fairy Tales | Raymond August Melan | Amanda Anna Livaudais |
| 1992 | Do You Know What It Means to Miss New Orleans? | Warren W. Wingerter, Jr. | Aline Marie Williams |
| 1991 | Follow Your Dreams | Frank Joseph Knecht, III. | Ramona Diane Williamson |
| 1990 | Memories | Joseph Michael Livaudais | Paula Ruth Catoire Foote |
| 1989 | Festivals of North Louisiana | Joseph Scott Knecht | Rachelle Halligan Livaudais |
| 1988 | Cities and Parishes of South Louisiana | Allen I. Boudreaux | None |
| 1987 | Truly American | Baptiste Debroy | Rebecca Plaisance |
| 1986 | The Best of Everything | Edward L. Crochet, Jr. | Shannon Maureen Fitzmorris |
| 1985 | Magical Moments in Music | Michael J. Bowler | Julie Beth VanGeffen |
| 1984 | As Time Goes By | Richard A. Hamilton, Sr. | Lydia Ann Bailey |
| 1983 | Cinema Classics | Emile P. Miller | Pamela Mary Villarrubia |
| 1982 | Wonders of the Sea | John J. Sehrt, Jr. | Pamela Ann VanGeffen |
| 1981 | Around the World with Songs | Salvador F. Centanni, Jr. | Francesca Marie Cuccia |
| 1980 | Holidays | James C. Farrelly | Lisa Marie Fitzmorris |
| 1979 | A Tribute to the Sunbelt States | Joseph David Cantalano, Sr. | Darni Dale Jordan |
| 1978 | The Four Seasons | John Francis Karl | Marlene Caldarera |
| 1977 | Toys | Vincent Arena | Lisa Restivo |
| 1976 | We the People | O.J. Viviano | Renee VanGeffen |
| 1975 | Theatre Tunes – Ladies and Lovers | Merrith Karl | Gia Rabito |
| 1974 | It’s 50 Years | Percy Chatelain | Kathleen VanGeffen |
| 1973 | The Golden Years of Broadway | John Minor | Kim VanGeffen |
| 1972 | Songs to Remember | George VanGeffen | Rebecca Heaton |
| 1971 | Silver Memories | Forrest R. Singer | Bridget Heaton |
| 1970 | Tales of History and Legend | Edward John Ziegler | Shelley VanGeffen |
| 1969 | The Sciences | Anthony A. Campo | Jo Ann Campo |
| 1968 | Saga of the Mississippi | Joseph P. Aucoin | Bonnie Lee Tunstall |
| 1967 | Highlights of American History | William James Lee, Jr. | Karen Ruth Richard |
| 1966 | Reveries Over a Scrapbook | Walter Gemeinhardt | Marie Margaret Mouton |
| 1965 | The Eternal Cycle | Louis D. Haeuser | Lurline Linda Watts |
| 1964 | Romantic Melodies | Carroll Denis VanGeffen, Sr. | Margaret Paul |
| 1963 | Myths and Legends | Martin J. Paul, Jr. | Karen Kaye Smith |
| 1962 | The Immortal Works of Victor Herbert | William B. Gatipon, Sr. | Melba Martin |
| 1961 | Memories of a Concert Hall | Earl A. Noble, Sr. | Linda Lee Normand |
| 1960 | The Nutcracker | John Joseph Matranga | Jeannine Claire Matranga |
| 1959 | Fantasy Land | Russell Leonard Cuoco | Carole Andree Cuoco |
| 1958 | The Glittering Festival | Fred J. Husser | Shirlee Gagliano |
| 1957 | Best Loved Poems | Manuel B. Zabala | Lorraine Centanni |
| 1956 | Bluebird | Frank C. Saporito | Barbara Mae Braud |
| 1955 | Toyland After Midnight | William A. Long, Sr. | Joy Ann Cuoco |
| 1954 | Between the Bookends | Joseph B. Exnicios | Rose Mary Gambino |
| 1953 | Wedding Anniversaries | John Mailhes | Yvette Anne Guillot |
| 1952 | Nature’s Colorful Realm | Dennis Rufin | Joy Ann Scheuring |
| 1951 | Scenes of Beauty | Salvador F. Centanni, Sr. | Myra Centanni |
| 1950 | The Rise and Fall of King Winter | Lucien Roland | Mildred Mary Long |
| 1949 | Holidays Around the World | Evertt Marks | Beth O’Neill |
| 1948 | Favorite Songs of the American Past | Adrian A. Arnaud | Mary Elise Exnicios |
| 1947 | Fantasy of Fairy Tales | John C. Ackermann | Ada Ruth (Mrs. Joseph) Rebaudo |
| 1946 | No Parades or Balls | N/A | N/A |
| 1945 | No Parades or Balls | N/A | N/A |
| 1944 | No Parades or Balls | N/A | N/A |
| 1943 | No Parades or Balls | N/A | N/A |
| 1942 | No Parades or Balls | N/A | N/A |
| 1941 | Ancient Lands | Lionel L. Janes, Jr. | Doris Dell |
| 1940 | The Kingdom of Nature | William Ahten | Claire Seeman |
| 1939 | Rhymes | William C. Gravlin | Beatrice Triche |
| 1938 | Holidays | William McKnight | Mary Ann Dayteen |
| 1937 | The Legend of the Masques | Henry Heaton | Margie Kampen |
| 1936 | Aladdin and His Wonderful Lamp | Charles R. Spahr | Addie Riera |
| 1935 | Unknown | Herman H. Seeman | Ferdinand Talbot |
| 1934 | Unknown | Edwin Heaton | Estelle Severina |
| 1933 | Happy Dreams | John B. Kramer | Edwina Heaton |
| 1932 | The Voice of the Air | Joseph B. Exnicios | Cecile Twiggs |
| 1931 | The Land of Art | Aubrey C. Heumann | Geneviene Hahn |
| 1930 | The Call of the Redmen | John Cozzo | Dolly Woods |
| 1929 | The Land of Nippon | William Betz, Sr. | None |
| 1928 | Unknown | M. George DeLucas | None |
| 1927 | Unknown | P. H. Lane | None |
| 1926 | Unknown | James B. Humphreys | None |
| 1925 | Unknown | Lawrence M. Thom | None |
| 1924 | No Theme – Marching Club | John Fordyce | None |